Post by account_disabled on Jan 11, 2024 1:18:37 GMT -8
survey, he will spend a year doing so. There is no time to implement what was raised in the diagnosis. ConJur — What about the idea of hiring a trained administrator to manage the court? Alexandre de Moraes — I disagree with this thesis. With all due respect, I think this is bullshit. The administrator knows nothing about the Judiciary. It's the same thing as saying that the president of the Chamber of Deputies cannot manage, he has to hire someone. ConJur — In a survey carried out by Consultor Jurídica , we found that around 60% of the federal laws questioned are considered unconstitutional.
For state companies, this rate rises to 70% and reaches 80% in the case of municipal ones. Why is the Constitution disrespected by the legislator himself? Alexandre de Moraes — In the case of the state, of this 70%, 80% is a failure of initiative, when the deputy tries to do something that is not app Phone Number List ropriate, that is, he sends a bill that could only be proposed by the governor. Other cases are competence defects, when the state Legislature invades the federal competence. There, interpretation matters a lot. Sometimes, Congress finds the matter constitutional and the Supreme Court says no.
But the problem is that both the Executive and the Legislative, when they take office, want to govern with their government plan, often ignoring the Constitution. It's an absurd. Congress disrespecting the Constitution that Congress itself created only happens in Brazil. ConJur — Around 80% of court administrative acts are considered unconstitutional by the Supreme Court. Does the Judiciary also disrespect the laws? Alexandre de Moraes — Several provisions were declared unconstitutional mainly because of the internal regulations of each court. Furthermore, on other issues, such as setting remuneration from the ceiling, each court sets regulations and interprets the Constitution in a different way.
For state companies, this rate rises to 70% and reaches 80% in the case of municipal ones. Why is the Constitution disrespected by the legislator himself? Alexandre de Moraes — In the case of the state, of this 70%, 80% is a failure of initiative, when the deputy tries to do something that is not app Phone Number List ropriate, that is, he sends a bill that could only be proposed by the governor. Other cases are competence defects, when the state Legislature invades the federal competence. There, interpretation matters a lot. Sometimes, Congress finds the matter constitutional and the Supreme Court says no.
But the problem is that both the Executive and the Legislative, when they take office, want to govern with their government plan, often ignoring the Constitution. It's an absurd. Congress disrespecting the Constitution that Congress itself created only happens in Brazil. ConJur — Around 80% of court administrative acts are considered unconstitutional by the Supreme Court. Does the Judiciary also disrespect the laws? Alexandre de Moraes — Several provisions were declared unconstitutional mainly because of the internal regulations of each court. Furthermore, on other issues, such as setting remuneration from the ceiling, each court sets regulations and interprets the Constitution in a different way.